Bruce Lawson’s personal site

Why I won’t clap for Boris

A right-wing friend got angry with me because I refused to “clap for Boris”, saying now is not the time to make political points.

If you think this is not a time to make political points, you’re wrong. Boris Johnson has Covid-19 because he went around shaking Covid patients’ hands, against expert advice. Those experts who, in 2016, Gove said everyone is tired of.

He shook people’s hands because he had a plan to boost herd immunity – we should all “take it on the chin” he said. This policy was dreamed up by him and Dominic Cummings, who said “herd immunity to protect the economy and if a few pensioners die, so be it”. That’s your dad and my mum he was prepared to sacrifice.

And because of this deranged policy (which models showed would cause the death of an extra quarter of a million British people), he delayed ordering the Personal Protective Equipment that the health workers need — the health workers whom he voted to deny a 1% payrise to. Mass testing and contact tracing are what got China and South Korea through this. But even the lefty paper the Daily Mail is reporting that the “herd immunity” delay means we won’t have enough of the chemicals needed to produce the 100,000 tests that Matt Hancock promised by the end of the month. (After Johnson falsely promised 250,000.)

In October 2016 the UK government ran a national pandemic flu exercise, codenamed Exercise Cygnus. “We’ve just had in the UK a three-day exercise on flu, on a pandemic that killed a lot of people,” chief medical officer Sally Davies said at the time. “It became clear that we could not cope with the excess bodies,” Davies said. One conclusion was that Britain, as Davies put it, faced the threat of “inadequate ventilation” in a future pandemic.

What did the Tory government at the time do? Nothing. Johnson was a senior Cabinet Minster at that time.

Matt Hancock was invited by the EU to collaborate in bulk-buying ventilators. Johnson said no, because he didn’t like the politics of collaborating with the EU. End result? We don’t have enough ventilators.

I hope he gets better, because I’m a socialist so I value his life more than he values mine (or yours). I hope he recovers and comes back more humble, more humane. And as a patriot, I will not stop holding to account this dangerous man whose bad political choices mean that UK will have Europe’s worst death toll:

In the early stages of the UK outbreak, deaths climbed steeply, which the IHME says is a major driver of predicted deaths.

The flirtation in government with the idea of “herd immunity” as a way out of the epidemic meant there was a delay in implementing physical distancing until 23 March, when there were already 54 daily deaths.

It is unequivocally evident that social distancing can, when well-implemented and maintained, control the epidemic, leading to declining death rates.

His political choices will cause far more of our compatriots to die than would have otherwise. His policies require scrutiny. He deserves no applause.

4 Responses to “ Why I won’t clap for Boris ”

Comment by Andy Mabbett

I want Johnson to live, because it’s evil to wish death on another.

But I also want him to be around when we have a review of what has happened, so he can see his failings exposed to the world, and not be hailed a martyr and a hero.

Comment by Charlie

For most of the same reasons as you list I want the man to be held accountable for his policies. But, as I think he’s a self-obsessed wanker, I would never applaud the guy for anything other than resigning; though I also think the applauding is yet another empty gesture in a country (it’s not just the government), that is not prepared to pay properly for the health service.

I don’t think the herd immunity policy was ever sensible but we must get some perspective on this: we still haven’t reached infection or fatality rates of a normal flu season. There has been a media frenzy here which has displaced most scientific reporting, and virtually every other issue. Flu epidemics regularly kill thousands of people yet we largely get on with life and most people ignore the dangers and don’t get a jab. Many of the same are now screaming for one for Covid-19.

All these deaths are individual tragedies but this does not mean that they justify the most extensive repression of civil liberties since the second world war. Some of the measures may indeed be justified but the transformation of a critical press into a essentially a loud-speaker for politicians certainly isn’t.

BTW covid-19 is highly infectious but doesn’t appear to be contagious. But if you’re close enough to shake someone’s hand, you’re close enough for them to infect you.

Comment by Lloydi

As I said to our esteemed friend Steve Faulkner earlier: I’d rather get the clap then give him a clap. And agree with all the above

Comment by Alex from Carlisle

Herd immunity wasn’t Boris’ plan. The government has been following what the experts tell them to do since the start, so really you’re badmouthing the medics and scientists. Odd that you’re not criticising Sweden or the netherlands for following teh same policy…

I don’t understand your right-wing friend getting angry about you not clapping though. I wouldn’t clap for any liberal, remoaner or Rotherham abuse enabler if they had it.

Leave a Reply

HTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong> . To display code, manually escape it.