Bruce Lawson's personal site

Why the HTML Outlining Algorithm was removed from the spec the truth will shock you!

Recently, the HTML spec changed to replace current outline algorithm with one based on heading levels. So the idea that you could use <h1> for a generic heading across your documents, and the browser would “know” which level it actually should be by its nesting inside <section> and other related “sectioning elements”, is no more.

This has caused a bit of anguish in my Twitter timelinewhy has this excellent method of making reusable components been taken away? Won’t that hurt accessibility as documents marked up that way will now have a completely flat structure? We know that 85.7% of screen reader users finding heading level useful.

Here comes the shocker: it has never worked. No web browser has implemented that outlining algorithm. If you used <h1> across your documents, it has always had a flat structure. Nothing has been taken away; this part of the spec has always been a wish, but has never been reality.

One of the reasons I liked having a W3C versioned specification for HTML is that it would reflect the reality of what browsers do on the date at the top of the spec. A living standard often includes things that aren’t yet implemented. And the worse thing about having zombie stuff in a spec is that lots of developers believe (in good faith) that it accurately reflects what’s implemented today.

So it’s good that this is removed from the WHATWG specification (now that the W3C specs are dead). I wish that you could use one generic heading everywhere, and its computed level were communicated to assistive technology. Back n 1991, Sir Uncle Timbo himself wrote

I would in fact prefer, instead of <H1>, <H2> etc for headings [those come from the AAP DTD] to have a nestable <SECTION>..</SECTION> element, and a generic <H>..</H> which at any level within the sections would produce the required level of heading.

But browsers vendors ignored both Sir Uncle Timbo, and me (the temerity!) and never implemented it, so removing this from the spec will actually improve accessibility.

(More detail and timeline in Adrian Roselli’s post There Is No Document Outline Algorithm.)

Buy "Calling For The Moon", my debut album of songs I wrote while living in Thailand, India, Turkey. (Only £2, on Bandcamp.)

One Response to “ Why the HTML Outlining Algorithm was removed from the spec the truth will shock you! ”

Comment by John Foliot

We almost got a generic <H>..</H> element in XHTML 2.0, but that poor spec died on the vine.

The closest thing to a generic heading markup today would be to use ARIA:

<div role="heading">        (which seems incomplete but is surprisingly still valid.)

Not that I’d ever recommend anyone actually do that, but there you have it.

Leave a Reply

HTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong> . To display code, manually escape it.